HOME & LIFESTYLE

How to Make Tomato Sauce From Scratch: Nancy Silverton’s Passata di Pomodoro

Pass canned San Marzano tomatoes through a food mill, season them, add basil and olive oil, then simmer about 30 minutes. That is Nancy Silverton’s passata di pomodoro, an Italian tomato sauce with a short ingredient list. This guide covers the tomatoes, the steps, what to cook with it and how to store it.

How to Make Tomato Sauce From Scratch: Nancy Silverton’s Passata di Pomodoro

What is passata di pomodoro?

Passata di pomodoro is an Italian tomato sauce made by passing tomatoes through a food mill. The name comes from the Italian passare, “to pass”, and the mill is what catches the seeds and skins so they never reach the sauce. Nancy Silverton teaches hers in the Peperonata with Passata lesson, as the first sub-recipe, Passata di Pomodoro. It is a multipurpose sauce for pasta or pizza, and she also uses it as the base of her baked peperonata.

Which tomatoes does Nancy Silverton use for tomato sauce?

Canned San Marzano tomatoes. In the lesson Nancy says they are the sweetest variety of tomato. The supplies list peeled plum tomatoes, preferably San Marzano, in two 28-ounce (800 g) cans, and the juices go into the mill with the tomatoes. That is 56 ounces in all, which is why the batch makes enough for the peperonata and plenty left over.

How do you make tomato sauce from scratch the way Nancy Silverton does?

The lesson lists:
Peeled plum tomatoes: 2 cans, 28 ounces (800 g) each, with their juices, preferably San Marzano
Kosher salt: 1 tablespoon
Sugar: 1 tablespoon
Black pepper: freshly ground, no amount given
Basil: 2 stalks
Extra-virgin olive oil: ¼ cup
Equipment: a food mill, a medium saucepan and a wooden spoon

1. Pass the canned tomatoes, with their juices, through the food mill into a medium saucepan.
2. Discard the seeds and skins left in the mill.
3. Set the saucepan over medium heat and add the salt, sugar and pepper, stirring to mix.
4. Add the basil and the olive oil and stir gently.
5. Reduce the heat to medium-low and simmer for about 30 minutes, until the sauce thickens slightly.
6. Take out the basil leaves.

Nancy cracks her pepper in a coffee grinder rather than a pepper mill. In the lesson she turns the heat off once the sauce is reduced enough, because it keeps reducing in the oven with the peppers. The lesson lists the sauce at about 35 minutes in all, only 5 of them hands-on, and the batch makes about 4 cups.

What can you make with homemade tomato sauce?

Pasta and pizza, as the lesson says, and Nancy’s peperonata, the Italian baked pepper dish this sauce was made for. She softens sliced peppers and onions in a pan with garlic, oregano, black pepper and a little sherry vinegar, which adds a sharp, acidic note against the sweetness of the peppers. The peppers then bake in the oven for close to an hour with the passata, which reduces further as they bake. The lesson uses 1 cup of the sauce for the peperonata and sets the other 3 cups aside for pasta or pizza. The black Taggiasca olives in her version are a small Ligurian olive that may need a well-stocked specialty store. A tomato sauce like this also goes between the layers of eggplant parmesan, which our eggplant parmesan guide explains.

What can you make with homemade tomato sauce?

How do you store homemade tomato sauce, and can you can it?

The lesson says the sauce keeps in a sterilized airtight container in the refrigerator for a week, or frozen for several months. USDA guidance for cooked leftovers is shorter, 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, so treat that as the safer limit and freeze whatever you will not use by then. Get it into the refrigerator or freezer within two hours of cooking, and leave a little room at the top of a freezer container, as the National Center for Home Food Preservation advises. Do not can it as written: the lesson does not teach canning, and that center’s tested tomato sauce recipes add bottled lemon juice or citric acid to each jar and use set processing times.

Make the sauce first on the day you bake the peperonata, so the 3 spare cups are ready for pasta or pizza. To cook it alongside the chef, learn it from Nancy Silverton.

Nancy Silverton
FEATURED YESCHEF INSTRUCTOR
Nancy Silverton

James Beard Award-winning chef, best-selling cookbook author, and the restaurateur behind Michelin-starred Mozza, Nancy Silverton takes viewers on a journey from her home in Panicale, Italy, to her home in Los Angeles. Viewers learn a range of Nancy’s renowned dishes, including her signature Caesar Salad, Chi Spacca Pepper Steak, 10+ vegetarian dishes, Mom’s Apple Pie, and more.

Explore The Class
How to Make Tomato Sauce From Scratch: Nancy Silverton’s Passata di Pomodoro | YesChef